May 14, 2014

Review: Dreams of Gods & Monsters by Laini Taylor

Dreams of Gods & Monsters by Laini Taylor
Series: Daughter of Smoke & Bone, #3
Published: 2014, Little, Brown and Company
Genre: Young Adult Fantasy
Source: Purchased
Contains spoilers for Daughter of Smoke & Bone (my review), Days of Blood & Starlight (my review)

History conditioned you for epic-scale calamity. Once, when she was studying the death tolls of battles in World War I, she’d caught herself thinking, Only eight thousand men died here. Well, that’s not many. Because next to, say, the million who died at the Somme, it wasn’t. The stupendous numbers deadened you to the merely tragic, and history didn’t average in the tame days for balance. On this day, no one in the world was murdered. A lion gave birth. Ladybugs lunched on aphids. A girl in love daydreamed all morning, neglecting her chores, and wasn’t even scolded.
What was more fantastical than a dull day?

Without a doubt, Dreams of Gods & Monsters was one of my most anticipated 2014 releases. Like so many others, I fell in love with the fantastical world that Laini Taylor has created, full of warring angels and demons and the two whose destiny may put an end to the conflict for good.

Over the course of two novels and a novella set within this world, Taylor has created dynamic, realistic characters, tense conflict, a reimagined battle of epic even Biblical proportions, all wrapped together in gorgeous prose. That all being said, I expected to love Dreams of Gods & Monsters, even as I expected to mourn the conclusion of a beloved series. But while I enjoyed the conclusion, I can’t say I was fully satisfied with it.

Karou has finally allowed herself to look past Akiva’s massive past transgressions (including the murder of Brimstone, her guardian and the only father-figure she’s known). After spending some time helping the White Wolf’s chimera army wreak just as much devastation on the seraphim, however, Karou comes to realize that the constant war wasn’t the vision that Madrigal (her past self) and Akiva had. Nor was it the future Brimstone sought. And so Karou reconciles with Akiva, and the two hope that the chimera army and Akiva’s band of Misbegotten rebel seraphim, can prevent the seraphim army from destroying Eretz, the land that both seraphim and chimera call home.

As Madrigal and Akiva, they never expected that their plans for a peaceful world would be easily achieved. As Karou and Akiva, they know that easy peace is not merely difficult, but downright impossible. But as Jael’s seraphim army threatens the human world in addition to Eretz, they plan to do whatever possible to achieve a long-sought peace.

The second book in the trilogy, Days of Blood & Starlight, is a book about war. But even as unrelentingly dark and gritty as it is, it is still about war as primarily observed from the sidelines (in Karou’s case in particular). Dreams of Gods & Monsters, however, puts war at the very forefront. Karou and Akiva fight against the seraphim army led by Jael many times. They watch friends die. They make tough choices that most readers cannot even begin to fathom.

Lest readers worry that this book is too dark, however, there’s a constant thread of hope running through the pages. Hope, in the form of Karou and Akiva, in the love they have for one another and the forgiveness they’re willing to bestow on each other and others who have wronged their loved ones over the years. At its heart, this is what the novel is about: what can be accomplished when people pin all their struggles on the promise of hope for a better future, of peace. It’s a fine enough message and works well within the context of the novel. But it also got to be a bit heavy-handed as the story went on. Again and again Karou and Akiva remind themselves that they represent hope for their people, that they must be the ones to enact change. True, but being force-fed that message many times made it feel as though Taylor didn’t trust her readers enough to let them discern such messages on their own. And for a book that is otherwise quite sophisticated, the repetition of this theme felt out of place.

For a book about war, the plot also seemed to lag quite a bit, especially in the beginning. At the end of Days of Blood & Starlight, Karou and Akiva have decided to move forward, to take action. But that action doesn’t occur right away (not much action at all for well over a hundred pages). Taylor has continued to expand her story’s world, adding in new characters and conflicts to the final installment. While all the new components do connect to the overarching story, they also contribute to the initial sense that the story is dragging. Readers must process so much information, and many of the plot threads don’t become linked until much later in the story.

This is not a perfect series conclusion, but it’s a satisfying one nonetheless. After the complete devastation and emotional trauma that has followed the characters since the middle of the first book, it’s nice to see the potential for good things to come to them once more. Karou and Akiva’s relationship is quite possibly the most complex aspect of this novel: on the one hand, it can sort of be classified as instalove, but it’s not that difficult to realize that it’s far, far more finely wrought than to be reduced to that term. In Dreams of Gods & Monsters, Karou finally comes into her own, as both the human girl Karou who was raised by monsters, and as the former chimera Madrigal. Her relationship with Akiva does not define her growth, but truly supplements it (and allows Akiva to gain some necessary development in the process). I have no complaints about the characterization of either of them.

The plot and the focus on the two protagonists does limit any development of the secondary characters, unfortunately. Taylor has some old and new characters share in the main conflict with Karou and Akiva, from the kirin Ziri, to the seraphim warrior Liraz, to the humans Mik and Zuzana, to the young scientist Eliza, who somehow ties all the threads together. I like the secondary characters, but for the most part they felt supplemental, their actions more important than their individual development.

Patience is perhaps the greatest asset that readers should possess when starting this novel. Taylor is a skilled writer and is able to tie everything together very well, but doing so takes a lot of time, and there are a lot of detours along the way. This isn’t quite the enthralling, utterly consuming story that can be found in Daughter of Smoke & Bone, “Night of Cake & Puppets,” or even Days of Blood & Starlight. For those invested in seeing how Karou and Akiva’s story ends up, however, the conclusion is still worth the time and effort.

Rating: 3.5 stars
author image


Amanda loves few things better than sitting down with a cup of tea and a book. She frequently stays up far too late, telling herself she just needs to finish one more page. When she's not wrapped up in the stories of others, Amanda works as a children's librarian in a public library.


  1. Yes! To all of the above! I had similar issues, and I felt like this book took awhile to actually get going and grab my interest (as in more than halfway through). I still did enjoy it, like you, but I was not completely satisfied as well. Oh well. I am still eager to see what Taylor has in store for us next! Beautifully written, Amanda!

    1. I think discussing this with you made me view it a bit more negatively, to be honest. So thanks for that! Otherwise, discussing it just helped me open my eyes to the things that didn't sit well with me.
      But, yeah, I'm definitely still a fan of Taylor and will read whatever she writes next.
      Thanks, Cort!

  2. I didn't struggle with the pacing much or find that patience was needed, likely because I'd read Laini Taylor's grocery lists though, but I completely agree that Eliza and the new plot threads introduced felt underdeveloped and unnecessary to the story as a whole. Still, I seriously enjoyed this one and it's one of my favorite trilogies to date, so no complaints from me! :)

    1. haha I mean I'm sure I *would* read Taylor's grocery lists as well. I think the tone - and story overall - somehow didn't quite match with what I was expecting. There's so much buildup in the first two and then the resolutions are quick at times, completely out of left field at other times. I just don't think it was as tightly constructed as it could have been.
      But I'm definitely still a fan of Taylor and glad that I read this trilogy. :)

  3. I haven't hopped onto this trilogy yet but I really really want to. The more I read about it, the more I want to read it. Then again, I have doubts whether I'd love it as much as other people did.

    1. Hype can definitely work against you with certain books. Taylor's trilogy, though, is worth the hype to me. I hope you do give it a try!

  4. I realize I'm a bit late with the commenting, but I'd bookmarked this review when I started reading this one myself and I was avoiding all reviews until I'd finished reading/reviewing for myself. I agree with you, while this was a satisfying ending to the series, it didn't quite live up to my expectations for it. You're right that it wasn't quite as all-consuming as the previous two books but I still ended up feeling satisfied for the most part. I do wish the conclusion of the chimera/angel war had been resolved for us to see first hand. And that new threat at the end could have done with more explaining. For some reason I feel like maybe a fourth book would have been perfect. Tone down this one a bit and then fully explore the new stuff in the next one. Anyways, I loved reading your thoughts on this one, great review ^^

    Micheline @ Lunar Rainbows Reviews

  5. I actually agree with almost everything you've said about this one, but I ended up rating the book five stars. This was one of those times, for me, where I recognized it had some weaknesses/flaws but my love for the writing and my emotional investment in the characters ended up overshadowing all of my complaints. That rarely happens for me, but it did with these books. I definitely wish there had been a bit more focus or that Eliza had been introduced earlier. She ended up being important obviously, but it felt like it took so long to find out why!


Thank you for taking the time to comment! I strive to make my blog the very best it can possibly be and I appreciate each and every comment on here.