November 13, 2013

Review: The Bone Season by Samantha Shannon

The Bone Season by Samantha Shannon
Series: The Bone Season, #1
Published: 2013, Bloomsbury USA
Genre: Adult Fantasy
Source: Library
Goodreads · Amazon · Barnes & Noble

Knowledge is dangerous. Once you know something, you can't get rid of it. You have to carry it. Always.

Samantha Shannon is no J.K. Rowling. As with Rowling, despite her authorial inexperience the British Shannon has famously received a publishing contract for a seven-book fantasy series. There all comparisons between Shannon and Rowling end, though, as they should. Shannon is not Rowling, but acknowledging Shannon for herself is not a bad thing.

In an alternate not-too-distant future, many of the world’s inhabitants find themselves under the rule of a harsh ruling body known as Scion. Scion is ostensibly there to protect so-called natural people from those unnaturals (clairvoyants) who possess the ability to communicate with the spirit world. Paige Mahoney is not only one of those clairvoyants, but she’s also a rare type called a dreamwalker, able to sense the presence of other clairvoyants (called voyants) by allowing her spirit to leave her body. For her own protection against a government that wishes her dead, Paige has spent the past few years working for the voyant criminal underworld.

The dangerous but carefully constructed life that she has made for herself disappears in an instant when Paige finds herself cornered by the NVD (voyants under the employ of Scion who seek out all the clairvoyants in hiding) and displays her very powerful skills. Shortly thereafter, Paige is captured and taken away from her London home to a prison in Oxford called Sheol I. She learns that the persecution and harm done to clairvoyants by Scion is only a fraction of all the dangers facing voyants. For in Sheol I, immortal beings called Rephaim have the power to not only drain the voyants’ auras, but also command them to fight against an even more sinister otherworldly enemy.

There is simply no way that any brief synopsis I’d write would truly encompass all this story is about there’s far too much going on here in Shannon’s debut. And I loved that. I love how ambitious this story is. In under 500 pages Shannon has introduced readers not merely to a fantasy world, but to an alternate reality of our world. Certain things have remained the same, certain progress has proceeded as normal, but they’re juxtaposed with magical events that have become fact, such as the existence of a type of person who has the ability to affect the aether (spirit world). It’s all very complex and fascinating and I found myself curious to try to spot the differences and similarities between this world and ours.

Shannon does have a tendency to overload readers with worldbuilding from time to time (the beginning one hundred pages in particular read really slowly), but I’ll always be of the opinion that it’s better to have too much information than too little. If anything, I wanted even more information on this world that Shannon has built. I wanted to know about this world’s foundations, and Scion’s claim that Edward VII’s reign is to blame for the appearance of clairvoyants. I wanted to better understand the history the Scion and the Rephiam have. I wanted to know more about the different types of voyants themselves. Shannon provides her readers with enough information to make sense of The Bone Season, perhaps, but I still expected more.

Not only is Shannon’s work rooted in history (what was and what could have been), but it seems to contain Biblical undertones. Although the Rephaim are never described as being Biblical or angels, it was all too easy for me to make associations to the vengeful angel warriors. The otherworldly enemies that the Rephaim force the voyants to fight are called Emim, another word with Biblical roots. It will be interesting to see how Shannon continues to describe these beings and their histories as the series continues.

I classify Shannon’s story as a fantasy, but it does have dystopian elements throughout. Paige’s world as a whole seems pretty bleak for clairvoyants, who either are forced to work for Scion as NVDs (a guaranteed life of 30 years, if they help the government track down other voyants), imprisoned, killed, or sent to the penal colony of Sheol I. Sheol I is not an option known to most voyants, but it is perhaps the worst of them all. Shannon does not forgo describing any of the horrors that voyants captured there have, nor the hierarchy and tests that make up their very existence. It’s frankly a pretty terrifying world for Paige and her fellow captive clairvoyants.

I quite liked Paige’s character. Through her, Shannon has skillfully mediated the line between another cliched fighter and the non-fighter too weak to stand on her own two feet. Paige knows how to protect herself on a basic level after living outside the law with her criminal voyant syndicate. She knows how to make her spirit leave her body so that she make seek out other voyant auras. But she’s still naive at the beginning of the story. She starts seeing the bigger picture of life for voyants in Scion, in Sheol I, and beyond, instead of focusing solely on her own needs. She learns how to take full advantage of her powers. She comes to see her Rephaim captor, Warden, not solely as an enemy, but as a captive himself of the system. And Paige finds that she’s willing to do whatever it takes to right some of these wrongs. Of course, there’s still much for Paige to learn as the first book reaches its conclusion.

Outside of Paige’s character, however, the other characters all felt a bit flat. I had trouble remembering who Paige’s friends were in Sheol I, and also the exact members of Paige’s voyant syndicate back in London. Shannon tried to make them distinct, but the focus of this story is really on Paige herself and her personal growth, and it seems that Shannon may need a bit more experience (and books) to convincingly focus on both characters and plot.

Debut or not, this series shows potential. The worldbuilding is fascinating (if not fully fleshed-out just yet), the conflicts surrounding clairvoyants, the Scion governmental system, the Rephaim, and the Emim have all been set up and I’m curious to see where Shannon takes them. Time will only tell if Shannon’s series will live up to the same standards set by the Harry Potter series, but for now I just know that I was entertained enough to see what happens to Paige and her world next.

Rating: 4 stars

author image


Amanda loves few things better than sitting down with a cup of tea and a book. She frequently stays up far too late, telling herself she just needs to finish one more page. When she's not wrapped up in the stories of others, Amanda works as a children's librarian in a public library.


  1. I'm so glad you enjoyed this one, Amanda. I loved the way in which we got to know Paige's character in this book and I felt it was very effective. Plus, this world is so fascinating. It really does have so much potential, so I hope it lives up and delivers on that completely.

    1. I'm glad that I enjoyed it as well! Fingers crossed the sequels will live up to the potential introduced here.

  2. I actually think you did a really great job at recapping this book. I've no idea how I'll remember it all when I start book 2, so I might have to come back and get a basic set up here! This is a book that I just wanted to discuss and discuss when I read it, which is a mark of a fantastic story for me. I love that it is so rich in world building, but still we want more. I'm glad you pointed out how much you liked Paige, because I've seen some negativity around her. But I agree, I thought she was distinct - not cookie cutter heroine - and I very much enjoyed her growth and her slow building relationship with Warden. I'll agree that all the secondaries were confusing. There were SO many of them, but I'm still lost. As we go back to London in the next book, I have a feeling that this will sort itself out. Let's hope that this series just keeps getting better! Thoughtful review as always, Amanda.

    1. Thanks, Lauren! haha I hope you do that. One of the main reasons I decided to start writing reviews was to give myself easy reminders of the synopsis and my thoughts of previous books in series. So hopefully this will work by the time the sequel rolls around. :)
      Really? I'm not sure what negative things you can say about Paige. I think she's a fairly well-constructed character and her actions all make reasonable sense. Hmm. I'll have to see if I can find the negative critiques to see what basis those naysayers have lol.
      Yes, I shall be hoping for more clarity as the series continues. We'll see.


Thank you for taking the time to comment! I strive to make my blog the very best it can possibly be and I appreciate each and every comment on here.